Which of the following if true would weaken the above argument ........

Logial Reasoning (CLAT) Statement - Arguments

`India is the only country in the world where, in the States which are governed by the Communist party, human rights are fully respected — and that is only because the Bill of Rights is firmly entrenched in our national Constitution. We can proudly say that our Constitution gave us a flying start and equipped us adequately to meet the challenges of the future.’

Which of the following, if true, would weaken the above argument?

Communist governments are motivated to respect human rights out of Communist principles, not Constitutional ones.

The Constitution of India is itself sympathetic to Communist principles.

Human rights need to be enforceable to have any meaning.

Countries without a strong culture of human rights are prone to oppressing minorities.

Explanation:

The argument states that the concept of human rights enshrined in the Constitution of India is the reason behind the Communist party’s respect for human rights (in India). Option (1) weakens the argument by stating that the communist governments are not motivated by the principles of the Constitution (of India). Instead they are motivated by their own Communist principle.