Question Should Judicial Activism be discouraged Argument I No it would lead to executive dictatorsh...........

Logial Reasoning (CLAT) Statement - Arguments

Download Solution PDF

Question: Should Judicial Activism be discouraged?

Argument I: No, it would lead to executive dictatorship

Argument II: Yes, Judiciary should stay in the constitutional limits

Argument I is strong

Argument II is strong

Both the arguments are strong

Both the arguments are weak

Explanation:

Judicial activism is a "philosophy of judicial decision-making whereby judges allow their personal views about public policy, among other factors, to guide their decisions." There is no wrong in pin pointing the faults in the system in advance. ‘Dictatorship’ may or may not be acquired by someone and that can happen with or without laws. Hence both the arguments are weak.