Who amongst the following has observed that under the Indian Penal Code such a maxim lsquo Actus non...........

Indian Penal Code (IPC) 1860 General Explanations

Who amongst the following has observed that under the Indian Penal Code such a maxim ‘Actus non facit reum nisi mens sit rea’ is wholly out of place?

J.D. Mayne, Criminal Law of India

H.S. Gour, Penal Law of India

Ratan Lal Dheeraj Lal, Law of Crimes

All of the above

छोटे Courses बड़े Results

Master General Explanations

Prepare through Micro-courses

Try Now

Explanation:

- J.D. Mayne, Criminal Law of India: J.D. Mayne has written extensively about Indian penal laws. He noted that traditional legal maxims like 'Actus non facit reum nisi mens sit rea' (an act does not make one guilty unless there is a guilty mind) might not fit perfectly within the framework of the Indian Penal Code.

- H.S. Gour, Penal Law of India: H.S. Gour is known for his authoritative work on Indian penal law and also expressed that this traditional maxim doesn’t align well with Indian legal context due to its unique statutory construction.

- Ratan Lal Dheeraj Lal, Law of Crimes: Ratan Lal Dheeraj Lal have also discussed this concept in their books, indicating that 'mens rea' is not always applicable in every aspect of the Indian Penal Code.

- ?? All of the above: All three authors have conveyed similar thoughts on the applicability of this legal maxim under the Indian Penal Code.