National Panchayati Raj Day is celebrated on April 24 every year as it was on this day that the panchayati raj system got constitutional recognition during P.V. Narasimha Rao’s tenure as PM. Seeking to empower rural local bodies financially and politically, the 73rd constitutional amendment stipulated transferring 29 items to local bodies, setting up state election commissions and finance commissions to conduct elections and enhance resources for local bodies, reserving one-third seats for women and, in proportion to their population, for SCs and STs in all three tiers, apart from forming gram sabhas with people’s participation.
A fully functional, responsive grassroots-level system of self-governance is a sine qua non for an effective democracy. The government should work towards making gram swaraj a reality by strengthening local self-governments and the three Ds- Decentralization, Devolution and Development - go hand in hand for better strengthening of local governments.
Sources of Income of Panchayats :
Panchayats can discharge their functions efficiently only if they have sufficient financial resources.For resources, Panchayats depend mainly on grants from State Government. They also have taxation powers and have some income from owned or vested assets.They may get a share in the taxes, duties, tolls and fees that are levied and collected by the State Government. The following are the financial resources Panchayats have, to perform their functions.
- Gram Panchayat: In most States the power of levying taxes is vested in Gram Panchayats. House tax, tax on cattle, immovable property, commercial crops, drainage tax, sanitation fee, tax on produce sold in the village, a fee for supply of water to households, lighting tax are some of the taxes and fees levied by Panchayats. Panchayats can also levy entertainment tax on temporarily stationed theatres, taxes on animals and non-mechanically propelled vehicles. Gram Panchayats also receive funds as income from property owned by them as common grounds, jungles, cattle ground etc. The sales proceeds of dung refuse and carcasses (dead bodies of animals) are also retained by Gram Panchayats. They also receive their share in land revenue from the State.
- Panchayat Samiti: Panchayat Samitis can impose tax on facilities provided by them as water for drinking or irrigation purposes, lighting arrangements, tolls for bridges maintained by them. The property of Panchayat Samitis includes public buildings, public roads constructed or maintained out of their funds and all land or other property transferred to them by the Panchayats receive income from the property vested in them. They also receive grants from the State Governments. Funds are transferred by Zila Panchayats or State Governments along with schemes to be implemented by the intermediate institutions of Panchayati Raj.
- Zila Parishad: Zila Parishads are also authorized to impose taxes. They may impose taxes on persons carrying on business in rural areas for six months, taxes on brokers, commission agents in markets established by them, also the tax on the sale of goods in these markets. Tax on land revenue can also be imposed by Zila Parishads. When development schemes are entrusted to them, necessary funds are also provided. They also receive grants from the State, donations from charitable institutions, and may also raise loans.
Problems with Finances of Panchayats :
Across the country, States have not given adequate attention to fiscal empowerment of the Panchayats. Some of the issues associated with their finances are discussed below:
- Heavy dependence on upper tiers of government: Panchayats are heavily dependent on government grant and internal resource generation at the panchayat level is weak. This is partly due to a thin tax domain and partly due to Panchayats’ own reluctance in collecting revenue.
- Inflexibility of funds: A major portion of the grants both from Union as well as the State Governments is scheme specific and panchayats have limited discretion and flexibility in incurring expenditures in such schemes
- Responsibilities do not match finances: In view of their own tight fiscal position, State Governments are not keen to devolve funds to panchayats. In most of the critical Eleventh Schedule matters like primary education, healthcare, water supply, sanitation and minor irrigation even now, it is the State Government which is directly responsible for implementation of these programmes and hence expenditure. Overall, a situation has been created where panchayats have responsibility but grossly inadequate resources.
Way ahead with Finances :
- Explore additional sources: In order to widen their tax base the PRIs will need to explore additional sources of revenue. Rural bodies need to look beyond the traditional areas of lands and buildings and augment their resources by operating in newly emerging sectors through innovative tax/non-tax measures e.g. fee on tourist vehicles, special amenities, restaurant, theatre, cyber café etc.
- Incentivising Better Performance: The Ministry of Panchayati Raj has evolved a Panchayats Empowerment and Accountability Fund (PEAF) to incentivize both empowerments of the Panchayats by the States, on the one hand, and accountability on the part of the Panchayats to Gram/Ward Sabhas on the other.
- Royalty from minerals: The role of State Governments should be limited to prescribing a band of rates for these taxes and levies. g. PRIs should be given a substantial share in the royalty from minerals collected by the State Government. This aspect should be considered by the SFCs while recommending grants to the PRIs.
- Primary authority over taxation: In the tax domain assigned to PRIs, Village Panchayats must have primary authority over taxation. However, where such taxation has inter- Panchayat ramifications, the local government institutions at higher levels – Intermediate Panchayat and Zila Parishad could be given concurrent powers subject to a ceiling. Whenever a tax/fee is imposed by the higher tier, such taxes should be collected by the concerned Village Panchayats.
Devolution of powers to local bodies:
- Government’s “Gram Uday Se Bharat Uday” programme underlines the importance of the concept: “Ram rajya would be incomplete without gram rajya”.
- The 73rd constitutional amendment gave effect to Article 40 of the Constitution, which is actually part of the DPSP.
- It states that the state shall take steps to organise village panchayats and endow them with such powers and authority along with the financial support as may be necessary to enable them to function as units of self-government.
Issues:
- Even though it has been more than two decades since local bodies have been constitutionally empowered, the devolution of 29 subjects to panchayats is not satisfactory in many states.
- It appears that a majority of states are showing little interest in devolving power and funds to local bodies and are taking only half-hearted measures.
- While states are seeking more powers and rightly so, they are not showing the same interest in devolving powers to local bodies along with the three Fs - funds, functions and functionaries.
- Holding elections to local bodies every five years should be made mandatory and there should be no discretion or scope for the states to either postpone or advance them.
Steps taken by the government:
- The recommendations of the 14th Finance Commission for providing grants to the tune of Rs 2,00,292 crore between 2015 and 2020 to gram panchayats (GPs) directly, and also released the allocations to rural local bodies has been accepted.
- 14th FC recommendation of devolving funds to states from 32% to 42% has been accepted.
- In addition to the funds received from the Centre and the states, the panchayats are also mandated by the 14th Finance Commission to generate their own resources.
Present situation:
In a study conducted by the ministry of Panchayati raj in 2014-15 on the Panchayat Devolution Index, which looked at the devolution of powers to Panchayati raj institutions (PRIs) in terms of the three Fs:
- Kerala topped the list in all parameters except funds.
- While Karnataka was best in transferring funds to PRIs.
- Though Sikkim did well in transferring functions, it was low on other parameters.
Way forward:
With the country’s democratic structure operating at three levels - national, state, and panchayats and nagar palikas - democracy would be more meaningful and robust when people participate in running their own affairs. However, this can be achieved only when states fully empower rural local bodies in terms of devolution of funds, decentralization of powers,and allow people to have a greater say in local area development and allow people to have a greater say in local area development.