Context: Recently, NITI Aayog sought to dispel the fear that India is favouring a closed economy by promoting 'Atmanirbhar' mission.
About ‘Atmanirbhar Bharat Abhiyan (or Self-reliant India Mission)’
- ‘Atmanirbhar Bharat Abhiyan (or Self-reliant India Mission)’ with an economic stimulus package — worth Rs 20 lakh crores aimed towards achieving the mission.
- The announced economic package is 10% of India’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP) in 2019-20.
- The Self-Reliant India Mission aims towards cutting down import dependence by focussing on substitution while improving safety compliance and quality goods to gain global market share.
- The Self-Reliance neither signifies any exclusionary or isolationist strategies but involves creation of a helping hand to the whole world.
The Mission is based on five pillars namely,
- Economy
- Infrastructure
- System
- Vibrant Demography
- Demand
Closed Economy
A closed economy is one that has no trading activity with outside economies.
- It is also known as protectionist market, which attempts to protect its domestic producers from international competition.
- It is entirely self-sufficient, which means no imports come into the country and no exports leave the country.
- The goal of a closed economy is to provide domestic consumers with everything they need from within the country's borders.
- Example- Brazil, Cuba, and North Korea
Pros:
- It protects domestic enterprises from foreign competitive enterprise.
- It is assumed to be self-sufficient so it does not have to think about the global economy.
- It avoids exchange rate risks and global economic shocks.
- Closed economy has no exposure to financial crisis spread through international trade. Besides, the exchange rate risk does not apply because there are no transactions with the external sector.
Cons-
- Maintaining a closed economy is difficult in modern society because raw materials, such as crude oil, play a vital role as inputs to final goods makes closed economies inefficient.
- Closed economies are counterintuitive to modern, liberal economic theory, which promotes the opening of domestic markets to international markets to capitalize on comparative advantages.
Open Economy
- An open economy is a type of economy where not only domestic factors but also entities in other countries engage in trade of products (goods and services).
- Examples of open Economy- The U.S., Canada, Western Europe, and Australia.
Advantages
- Open economy leads to higher Gross Domestic Product (GDP).
- Open economies are able to get cheaper imports and can sell exports at higher prices.
- It emphasis on Improved Availability of Goods and Services.
- It leads to rapid economic growth.
- It provides an incentive for research and adoption of innovations.
Disadvantages
- Open economies are interdependent and are prone to risks.
- Intensity of the initial disturbance leads to greater damage to the interconnected open economies.
- Economies with greater restrictions on international economic transactions tend to suffer less when a disturbance originates in some other country.
- Large amounts of “footloose” (that is, short term and/or speculative type) funds are moving around the world.
- Certain varieties of imports can expose a country to undue political, economic and cultural risk.
- Large scale increase in international capital flows has resulted in heavy indebtedness.
Features
- It buys shares, debentures, bonds etc. from foreign countries and sells shares, debentures, bonds etc. to foreign countries.
- It borrows from foreign countries and lends to foreign countries.
- Normal residents of an open economy can move or be employed and are allowed to work in the domestic territory of other economies.
- Due to these reasons, Gross Domestic Product and Gross National Product are not same in an open economy.
- Prices are also found to be low and the qualities of products are better due to increased competition.
- There can be more choices for consumption.
- Open Economy is more flexible as it has a greater chance of adjusting itself with the changes taking place in world economy.